TO THE HONORABLE EDMUND G. BROWN, JR. FROM EXPERTS WORLDWIDE IN OPPOSITION TO SB 649
September 19, 2017
Dear Gov. Brown:
SB 649 is on your desk awaiting your decision, and we respectfully urge a veto. This bill denies citizens and local governments the right to a voice as to where 50,000 or more new cell towers, spaced every two to ten homes, will soon be placed. Telecom will be erecting towers in the rights-of-way, and placing them on utility poles and lampposts in front of our homes, schools, places of worship and businesses. There will be no escaping the cell towers or the radiation emitted from them. SB 649 fails to mandate monitoring of radiation levels from these cell towers at a time when the FCC is closing their regional monitoring offices. A failure to monitor is a failure to regulate.
SB 649 has passed through the Senate and Assembly despite opposition from the cities of Los Angeles, San Francisco, and San Jose as well as 300 other cities, the Teamsters, AARP, Environmental Working Group, Environmental Health Trust, Communications Workers of America, the League of Cities, California Brain Tumor Association, a host of environmental and justice groups, and leaders of 47 out of 58 California counties.
There is a substantial body of evidence that this technology is harmful to humans and the environment. The 5G millimeter wave is known to heat the eyes, skin and testes, and the ubiquitous placement of these towers will expose California’s population 24/7. Of particular concern are the most vulnerable among us -- the unborn, children, the infirm, the elderly and the disabled. It is also expected that populations of bees and birds will drastically decline.
Ironically, the strongest among us, the firefighters, received an exemption from SB 649. After years of their stations being targeted for cell tower placement, SPECT brain scan testing among a group of California firefighters revealed abnormalities that included cognitive impairment. This translated to firefighters occasionally getting lost while driving their emergency equipment through the streets in the same town they grew up in. Infertility and miscarriages plagued the department. Perhaps most shocking of all, the cell tower near the station was measured at 1/1000th of the allowed limit set by the FCC.
We support the fire station exemption of SB 649. If the firefighters are impaired, we are all at risk. Yet this exemption protects the strongest of the strong and forces the most vulnerable among us to live with the greatest exposure. We find that unacceptable. We also find the health risks both real and deeply concerning. In May 2016 the National Toxicology Program, part of the U.S. National Institutes of Health, released partial results of a $25,000,000 study on laboratory animals which showed a link between the RF (wireless) radiation and two types of cancer, prompting the American Cancer Society’s chief medical officer to note that the results “mark a paradigm shift in our understanding of radiation and cancer risk.’’ The NTP study also found DNA breakage in brain cells, confirming multiple studies dating back to 1994. The NTP study follows the 2011 classification by IARC, the World Health Organization's cancer committee, of radiofrequency electromagnetic fields -- including cell tower radiation -- as possibly carcinogenic to humans. This puts RF radiation in the same category as DDT. Our children are not just our progeny but the future of our state and our country. Keeping them safe must be a priority. Our homes must remain our sanctuaries. We currently have the option to turn wireless off at night, or to not use it at all. With SB 649 there is no "off" switch. Not only will SB 649 tie our hands as parents and private citizens, but this bill usurps ALL local control.
In a time that begs for strong compassionate leaders, we are turning to you to reject this bill, and work with independent health and technology experts from around the world to devise a safer solution so that we can stay connected yet protected.
Lennart Hardell, MD, PhD Senior Consultant Department of Oncology University Hospital Orebro, Sweden
Frank Clegg CEO, Canadians for Safe Technology (C4ST), Oakville, Canada Former President, Microsoft Canada
Cindy Sage Sage Associates Co-Editor, BioInitiative Reports Montecito, California
Martin Blank, PhD Department of Physiology (Ret) Columbia University New York City, New York
Anthony B. Miller, MD Professor Emeritus Dalla Lana School of Public Health University of Toronto Canada
Devra Davis, PhD, MPH Visiting Professor, Hebrew University Hadassah Medical Center & Ondokuz Mayis University Medical School President, Environmental Health Trust Teton Village, Wyoming 83025
Beatrice A. Golomb, MD, PhD Professor of Medicine UCSD School of Medicine San Diego, California
Cindy Russell, MD Physicians for Safe Technology Menlo Park, California
Susan Foster Medical Writer & Organizer, SPECT Brain Scan Study of California Firefighter (2004) Honorary Firefighter, San Diego Fire Department Rancho Santa Fe, California
Ellie Marks, Director California Brain Tumor Association San Francisco, California
Andrew A. Marino, PhD, JD Professor, Department of Neurology (Ret) LSU Medical School Shreveport, Louisiana
Jerry L. Phillips, PhD Executive Director, Excel Centers Professor Attendant, Department of Chemistry & Biochemistry University of Colorado Colorado Springs, Colorado
Martin L. Pall, PhD Professor Emeritus of Biochemistry and Basic Medical Sciences Washington State University Pullman, Washington
Elihu D. Richter, MD, MPH Professor, The Hebrew University of Jerusalem The Hebrew University of Jerusalem Jerusalem Area, Israel Paul Héroux, PhD Occupational Health Program Director Department of Epidemiology, Biostatistics and Occupational Health McGill University Medicine Montreal, Canada
Dr. Yael Stein MD Physician and researcher of health effects of electromagnetic radiation Hebrew University – Hadassah Medical Center Jerusalem, Israel
Dr. Erica Mallery-Blythe BMBS Soton Founder of PHIRE (Physicians' Health Initiative for Radiation and Environment) Trustee RRT (Radiation Research Trust) Scientific Advisor ORSAA (Oceania Radiofrequency Advisory Association) Medical Advisor ES-UK United Kingdom
William J. Rea, M.D. Environmental Health Center - Dallas Dallas, Texas